All Ratings

Sort Ratings
Village Brewhouse

Great consistency. Very tart, creamy texture and the crust is firm but not too crisp. Presentation is average

Location:

Punta Gorda, FL

Visited:

April 15, 2025

Rating:

4.9
Sweet Savannah’s

Creamy texture, gives a custard vibe. Nice and lightly tart. Crust is spot on

Location:

Florida Keys, FL

Visited:

April 5, 2025

Rating:

4.8
Riviera Bar and Grill

Creamier texture, crust is light and flakey, pie is tart. Good presentation with green gel.

Location:

Punta Gorda, FL

Visited:

April 2, 2025

Rating:

4.5
Mel’s diner

Firm texture. Cheesecake style. Great crust but lime is not tart enough

Location:

Cape Coral, FL

Visited:

March 26, 2025

Rating:

4
Tavern on the Bay

Smaller size but tart. Crust was thick but good. Thicker like a cheese cake

Location:

Naples, FL

Visited:

March 25, 2025

Rating:

4.7
The Boathouse

Tart and consistency is great. Crust is crumbly but holds together

Location:

North Ft Myers, FL

Visited:

March 16, 2025

Rating:

4.9
Sharkeys

Large size, great texture and great crust. Not tart enough

Location:

Venice, FL

Visited:

March 5, 2025

Rating:

4.2
Sea Craft

Like a cheesecake not as tart as it should be – thick, good crust. Served as a square

Location:

North Ft Myers

Visited:

February 12, 2025

Rating:

3.1
Dixie Fish Company

Crust was a bit flakey, lime was firm and tart!

Location:

Fort Myers Beach, FL

Visited:

February 6, 2025

Rating:

4.8