All Ratings

Sort Ratings
Riviera

Consistent as always

Location:

Punta Gorda

Visited:

September 12, 2026

Rating:

4.8
Nauti Parrot

Two layer pie. Bottom crust if firm and good. Not very thick but tastes good. Bottom half of filling is tart and firm. Top half is a bit fluffier but not as tart. A bit too much lime gel on the side but good whipped cream amount.

Location:

North Fort Myers, FL

Visited:

June 10, 2026

Rating:

4.6
The Boathouse Ft Myers

Great crust. Crunch and decent thickness. Small amount of whipped cream at the end which is good. Good tartness and great consistency. Green gel looks good but doesn’t add flavor. Gel brings it down.

Location:

Ft Myers, FL

Visited:

April 11, 2026

Rating:

4.8
Edwards from Walmart

Pie is creamy, a little less firm but good consistency. Could’ve more tart. Crust is good thickness but a bit crumbly. Not tart enough.

Location:

John and Kristine’s

Visited:

March 28, 2026

Rating:

4.1
Riviera

Nice presentation – cute but minimal gel and not too much whipped topping; great tartness, perfect consistency, perfect crust; slice was a bit on the small side

Location:

Punta Gorda

Visited:

March 23, 2026

Rating:

4.9
Doc Ford’s Rum Bar & Grille

Crust is thicker and still has a little crunch. Pie consistency is really good. Love that the whipped cream is on the side. Not tart enough at all. Didn’t like the raspberry under it.

Location:

Ft. Myers Beach

Visited:

February 15, 2026

Rating:

4
Village Brewhouse

Perfect, Very tart, creamy yet firm texture. Graham cracker crust is crunchy, but not crumbly.

Location:

Punta Gorda, FL

Visited:

February 10, 2026

Rating:

5
Lobster Lady

Overdone presentation

Location:

Cape Coral, FL

Visited:

April 30, 2024

Rating:

4
Publix

Great crust. Pie is not tart enough at all. A little runny and too much whipped cream.

Location:

North Ft Myers, FL

Visited:

November 16, 2025

Rating:

3.8