All Ratings

Sort Ratings
Doc Ford’s Rum Bar & Grille

Crust is thicker and still has a little crunch. Pie consistency is really good. Love that the whipped cream is on the side. Not tart enough at all. Didn’t like the raspberry under it.

Location:

Ft. Myers Beach

Visited:

February 15, 2026

Rating:

4
Village Brewhouse

Perfect, Very tart, creamy yet firm texture. Graham cracker crust is crunchy, but not crumbly.

Location:

Punta Gorda, FL

Visited:

February 10, 2026

Rating:

5
Lobster Lady

Overdone presentation

Location:

Cape Coral, FL

Visited:

April 30, 2024

Rating:

4
Publix

Great crust. Pie is not tart enough at all. A little runny and too much whipped cream.

Location:

North Ft Myers, FL

Visited:

November 16, 2025

Rating:

3.8
TT’s

Perfect texture. Crust is crunchy and the perfect thickness. Pie is tart and and a great texture. Could be more tart

Location:

Punta Gorda, FL

Visited:

April 13, 2025

Rating:

4.6
Village Brewhouse

Great consistency. Very tart, creamy texture and the crust is firm but not too crisp. Presentation is average

Location:

Punta Gorda, FL

Visited:

April 15, 2025

Rating:

4.9
Sweet Savannah’s

Creamy texture, gives a custard vibe. Nice and lightly tart. Crust is spot on

Location:

Florida Keys, FL

Visited:

April 5, 2025

Rating:

4.8
Riviera Bar and Grill

Creamier texture, crust is light and flakey, pie is tart. Good presentation with green gel.

Location:

Punta Gorda, FL

Visited:

April 2, 2025

Rating:

4.5
Mel’s diner

Firm texture. Cheesecake style. Great crust but lime is not tart enough

Location:

Cape Coral, FL

Visited:

March 26, 2025

Rating:

4